kitchen layout - which looks better ?

6 months ago

last modified: 6 months ago

Howdens have deisgned the following for the main run of my units - with 5 wall fluted glass units - not symmetrical either side of AGA as it's already in place and can't be moved, but I don't mind that. I just think there are too many wall units which makes it look top heavy ( the fluted glass wall units look better in real life - they look pretty awful in the CAD photo below - the photo below from their brochure does them better justice ! )

I prefer this - with 2 half height wall units on the right hand side with an open shelf beneath - preferably a floating quarz shelf above the upstand which will be 300mm high .

Which looks better do you think ?

Apologies for appalling photo quality - got crumpled in my bag !

Featured Answer

Sonia

6 months ago

How easy are the fluted doors to clean? That would be an important element for me. It will also mean you can only store “tidy” stuff in those cupboards. If you have plenty of storage elsewhere then I’d be tempted to ditch the wall units altogether. It looks very heavy. Some lovely shelves would look great.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

Daisy England
6 months ago
I’m not a lover of glass fronted units as l feel you have to have something showy to display.

l presume you have sufficient storage elsewhere in the kitchen?

If l had to choose out of the 2 options l would go with the first option. l think having different size wall units on one side looks unbalanced and the shelf seems pointless.
poppophouse
Original Author
6 months ago
Fortunately there will be loads of storage elsewhere in the kitchen . I guess the shelf does look a little pointless in isolation but I felt it might soften that big block of 5 units in a row but as you said , you have to think about what you can put in glass fronted cabinets although the fluted glass means the contents won’t be quite as exposed . Having never had wall cabinets in previous kitchens , I was keen to incorporate some but maybe I don’t need so many.
Related Discussions
Kitchen help - what can we do to make it look better?
Q
Comments (65)
Depending on how far you budget goes, I would look at adding traditional cornice and pelmet and replacing the plinth with a similar oyster colour. End panels for wall units could also be replaced / added. Some chessboard style tilling in 3 colours would also bring out the walls. It's hard to tell but is the oak surround also on the wall units? I haven't checked your location but this is something we can help with
...See More
Island unit vs peninsular - which kitchen layout do you prefer?
Q
Comments (1)
I think kitchen islands work better in larger rooms, to help break up the space. The second would work better to increase the feeling of space so I guess it depends on your situation but I like both!
...See More
Which is better. Kitchen A or B?
Q
Comments (15)
Yes, i think my dad was either low on budgetz or... He wqs just too tired to build a toilet for that one house. Anyway, I agree the new flow is much more inviting & i the kitchen is mid size, coz if I were to create as the plan, it would be around a 14' by 10' kitchen. A big on the budget, but doable. I would not though have a big Living/lounge. So, I will just utilise one of the 180sqft bedroom as a living (we don't really have that much furniture to fill a 360sqft living room!) . The other Bedroom left as it is (storage since we don't have a storage area/room). Maybe in future i will expand on that. Maybe, I'll upload some pictures of the after someday! Thanks.
...See More
Struggling with part of kitchen layout - which would you choose?
Q
Comments (9)
@Leesha- the illustrations shows side by side ovens that do not match. Some manufacturers now make appliances designed to sit side by side where the control panels are the same size and the handles are at the same height so even if you put a single oven with a steam oven side by side with a coffee maker, microwave and warming drawer the horizontal lines will line up. Look up Seimens ovens to see some images
...See More
PRO
Plews Garden Design
6 months ago
As the Aga isn’t moveable you need to work with asymmetry to achieve a visual balance.

Questions & suggestions

1] Is the sink also stuck in that location?

If so, why not have shelves instead of a cupboard over the sink – eg for pretty china that needs to be handwashed with glass fronted shelves on either side and far side of aga

2] do you items to display, jugs, antique glassware etc?

Then try clear glass instead of fluted

3] if you have enough storage elsewhere then why not treat this just as a cooking items needed next to aga area, ie only store such things as as herbs and spices, utensils on the wall . Or even some of your prettier pans, they can look remarkably decorative set out as ‘batterie de cuisine’

4] and on the display point have open wall on the sink side - for a shelf with some plants next to the window, a plate rack, food – themed prints etc. Then wall cupboard on the other, shorter side so there is a visual balance

Marie
CWD
6 months ago
Howdens main job is to sell you as many cabinets as they can squeeze into your room. I'd also opt for no wall units and see how you get on. You can always add them later if you need more storage, but sounds like you don't need it. It'll be much nicer above sink not to have units there. Do you need that unit above the AGA? That's making it feel heavier too I think - if that was just the pipe going up and out of the wall, it would open up the space a little more. I don't think you have enough space, but if you could squeeze in a counter-top unit to the right of the AGA that could be an alternative, with a long shelf above the sink instead of wall units there? I think you'd miss the worktop space though.
Jen
6 months ago
I agree - in a kitchen this size (with sufficient storage elsewhere) it would look fabulous, and luxurious, to ditch the wall units altogether.
Tani H-S
6 months ago
I also agree that if you have and need the units then the first picture looks nice.

I think though you could also compromise and have two slim height, wider floating (as in not attached to either side of the wall) wall units with nothing above the aga at all. And it feel more spacious and airy. Also shelves under each one would work. Can't find a pic to say what I mean at the minute but they would feel less cluttered but not leave the wall bare.
Anna G
6 months ago
I'm in total agreement with all the great advice and have some boring practical stuff to add. The unit over the sink is way too low, I've got a higher cabinet over mine and I still bump my forehead washing up. Underside of cabinets by the hob get dirty. Tops of cabinets get dirty. I love my wall cabinets, couldn't do without them but if I had room it'd just be a combo of base units and floor to ceiling units.
Nikki Larsen
6 months ago
I think the shelf off to one side like that looks unbalanced. Can you have a shelf on another wall? With glass units showing through various colours and a shelf, you’re going to find it hard to keep it looking tidy and styled.
poppophouse
Original Author
6 months ago
Thanks everyone - a couple of things I should have added - the Aga generates a lot of grease, even though it is externally vented so I reckon I'd be forever cleaning any expansive open shelving . I'd have loved all open shelving otherwise. Also because of the depth of the Aga, the base units have had to be moved forwards by about 12cm so that they're flush with the front of the Aga so we've got an extra depth to the worktop. That means there's less chance of banging our heads on the wall units ! The sink does have to go where it is unfortunately so no scope to move that .
siobhanmcgee90
6 months ago
Pet peeve of mine is having wall units that do not go to ceiling height. Loss of potential storage and hiding place for dust and grime. I know the reeded glass is very current but wonder, like others, about keeping them clean. Can you move the sink to under the window by putting in a corner and small unit there? I cannot see where your fridge is in this layout.
siobhanmcgee90
6 months ago
Meant to say the symmetrical design is better.
Isla Cherry
5 months ago
I think I am allergic to wall units. I have always replaced them with a shelf or two. They are looking quite old fashioned now especially when packed in a tight run. I feel claustrophobic with them over my head when prepping.

kitchen layout - which looks better ?

Sonia

Comments (14)

Daisy England

poppophouse
Original Author

Related Discussions

Plews Garden Design

CWD

Jen

Tani H-S

Anna G

Nikki Larsen

poppophouse
Original Author

siobhanmcgee90

siobhanmcgee90

Isla Cherry

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

kitchen layout - which looks better ?

Comments (14)

poppophouseOriginal Author

Related Discussions

poppophouseOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

poppophouse
Original Author

poppophouse
Original Author